Puerto Rico Board Game Strategy | How to Win with 7 Roles

Puerto Rico is a 3 to 5 player economy game with no dice, seven rotating roles, and roughly 15 rounds, where shipping any good always pays exactly 1 victory point per case, so almost all of your score comes from the buildings you choose to build.

If you have played Catan to death and you want the next step, this is usually the step. Puerto Rico is the game I reach for once my family is bored of waiting on dice rolls. It is the same satisfaction as Splendor, which is watching a small machine come together, except Puerto Rico removes the luck almost entirely and makes every player fight over a shared pool of jobs instead of their own private turn.

Two things separate it from almost every other game on the shelf. First, there are no dice, which puts it at the far end of the scale from games where randomness decides your fate, so nothing that happens to you is ever pure chance. Second, and this is the part almost every summary gets wrong, a role is not chosen once per round by one player. Every round is a queue where a different player picks each role in turn, and everyone at the table performs that role. That single detail is the whole game, and it is where the strategy lives.

Affiliate disclosure: this page contains Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you, and it never changes the verdict below.

The one rule that makes Puerto Rico different

Here is the round, and it is not what most pages say. The player with the governor placard starts. He takes one of the seven role placards, puts it by his board, and takes that role’s action. Then his left neighbor performs that same role, and so on around the table until every player has taken that action once.

Then the governor’s left neighbor takes his turn as the next chooser. He takes one of the remaining roles, and again everyone performs it. This continues until every player has claimed a role and the whole table has acted on each of them. Finally, one doubloon is placed on each of the three roles nobody took, and the chooser role passes to the left for the next round.

So it is not “one player picks a role.” It is a rotating draft. Every single player picks exactly one role per round, in order, and every other player benefits from each of those picks. The tension is that you want a role badly, but the player who picks before you might take it, and the roles nobody wants get richer for taking later.

Three rules sit under that and they matter:

• Unwanted roles bank money. If a role has one or more doubloons sitting on it, whoever finally takes it keeps those doubloons on top of the normal benefit. A role nobody wanted becomes a salary.
• The Captain is the only compulsory role. Every role is optional except Captain. If you can load goods onto a ship, you must.
• The governor rotates. The placard moves one seat to the left each round, so the first pick moves around the table across the game.

The seven roles and what each one does

These are all of them. The old version of this page named four and quietly dropped three, which makes the game impossible to follow.

Role	Privilege for the player who picks it	What everyone else does
Settler	Takes a plantation tile first	Everyone may take a plantation tile
Mayor	Takes a colonist off the ship first, plus a bonus colonist	Everyone takes colonists from the ship
Builder	Pays 1 doubloon less on a building	Everyone may build a building
Craftsman	Earns an extra good when producing	Everyone produces goods from manned plantations
Trader	Sells one good and earns 1 doubloon on top	Everyone may sell one good to the trading house
Captain	Loads goods onto a ship first, and selects the ship	Everyone may load goods for victory points
Prospector	Takes 1 doubloon from the bank	Nothing, it is a pure income pick

The Prospector is the one that rewards picking late. By the time it comes around with three doubloons stacked on it, it can be the best salary on the table, which is exactly why the queue order is a skill and not just turn taking.

Shipping pays the same for every good

This is the correction the old page got badly wrong, and it is one a player would play worse for believing.

The rulebook is explicit: when you load goods onto a cargo ship, all goods are worth the same, 1 victory point per case loaded. The goods values that matter in the trading phase are not used when shipping. There is no escalation. Coffee does not ship for more than corn.

What coffee actually is good at is selling, not shipping. In the Trader phase the trading house pays a printed price for each good in a range of 0 to 4 doubloons, plus the picking player earns 1 doubloon as a privilege. The trading house only ever holds four goods at a time, and it only buys kinds it does not already have. I am deliberately not printing the exact per good prices here, because those figures are printed on the board graphic and I have not verified each one against a source I can name. What you can rely on is the rule: shipping is a flat 1 VP per case for every good, and selling is where goods differ in cash.

That is the engine in one line. Goods are a means to fill ships, and ships are points, and points plus buildings are the game.

How a game of Puerto Rico ends

The old page never stated an end condition, which is one of the most load bearing rules in the game. A round finishes, and then the game ends, the moment any one of these three is true at its named phase:

Trigger	When it is checked
Not enough colonists left to fill the colonist ship	End of the Mayor phase
A player builds on his 12th city space	During the Builder phase
The last victory point chip is taken	During the Captain phase

Your final score is the victory point chips you have collected, plus the victory points printed on your buildings, plus the bonus points from any occupied large buildings. Buildings are not just a money engine, they are a big slice of your score, which is the piece new players underweight.

Setting up: the exact numbers by player count

These come straight from the setup chart in the rulebook, and they are the numbers a table actually argues about.

Player count	Roles used	Cargo ship sizes	Colonists in supply	Starting doubloons	Colonist ship
3 players	5 roles	4, 5, 6	55	2	3
4 players	7 roles	5, 6, 7	75	3	4
5 players	8 roles	6, 7, 8	95	4	5

Two things fall out of that chart. The roles used are all eight minus one Prospector at three players and minus one Prospector at four players, because the Prospector is the one role that can be taken twice in a round. And the cargo ships grow as the table grows, so five players is not just more competition, it is a longer, tighter shipping race.

The money is metal and the colonists are octagons

Two component corrections that would save you money at the shelf.

The box already comes with metal coins. The official component list reads “60 doubloons, golden metal tokens.” The base game ships sixty gold colored metal doubloons. The old page told you the money was cardboard and then recommended buying an upgrade, which is backwards. You already have the upgrade.

There are no barrels. There are one hundred colonists, which are brown octagonal wooden tokens, plus fifty wooden goods tokens shaped like chests. The old page called them “100 brown barrels,” which gets the number right and the noun wrong. Those one hundred tokens are the colonists you place on plantations and buildings, and they are the thing that quietly runs your entire engine.

The full box also holds 49 buildings, being five large beige, 24 small beige, and 20 colorful production buildings, and 58 island tiles, being 8 quarries and 50 plantations split 8 coffee, 9 tobacco, 10 corn, 11 sugar and 12 indigo. It was designed by Andreas Seyfarth, published by Ravensburger in German and Rio Grande Games in English, and first released in 2002.

Playing with two: there is no ghost player

The old page claimed two players need a variant “involving a ghost player.” There is no ghost player. The word does not appear anywhere in the rulebook. The base game is built for 3 to 5 players, and the two player game is its own short section that changes which components you set up. It is a real, differently tuned game, not the base game with a phantom bolted on.

If two player is your default mode, that is worth knowing before you buy. Puerto Rico is at its best from three up.

Building the engine: corn, quarries, and the factory

The early game is a race for production, and the old page sketched three routes but got the Factory wrong in a way that changes how you play it.

Corn versus quarry. Corn is cheap to get going and feeds an early shipping race, because you can produce without a processing plant and start filling ships sooner. Quarries do the opposite, they cut the cost of your buildings so you can afford the large violet ones that score and pay out all game. Both are legitimate, and which is better depends on what the table is doing with the ships.

The Factory rewards variety, not volume. This is the correction. If you own an occupied Factory and you produce more than one kind of good in the Craftsman phase, the Factory pays you from the bank like this:

Different goods produced in one phase	Factory pays you
1 kind	nothing
2 kinds	1 doubloon
3 kinds	2 doubloons
4 kinds	3 doubloons
All 5 kinds	5 doubloons

The number of cases plays no part. What matters is how many different goods you made, so the Factory pushes you toward a varied plantation rather than a monoculture. “Every time you produce goods” is the wrong way to read it, because it sounds like a per case bonus. It is a per kind bonus, once per Craftsman phase.

Replay value, honestly

The old page claimed buildings are randomized out of play so “not every building is available in every game,” and then concluded replay value was nearly infinite. The first half is not right and the second half is a claim the house rules do not allow.

Nothing gets removed from play. The 49 buildings are all there. What changes game to game is the setup, where only some buildings are dealt out to start and the rest become available as the game goes on, which is why “the Factory got snapped up early” is a real, common observation even though no building is ever missing. The variety is real, but it comes from the setup race and the shared role draft, the same way Carcassonne changes every time a different tile comes out, not from buildings disappearing. That is a genuine reason to keep playing, and it does not need an “infinite” that the rules do not support.

• Similarities: Both are quiet, satisfying engine builders where nobody is attacked directly and every point comes from a machine you assemble.
• Differences: Puerto Rico has zero dice and a rotating shared role draft; Splendor has reserve luck and a fixed private turn with no shared action pool.
• Why this game fans will enjoy it: If Splendor is your family's engine builder, Puerto Rico is the same feeling with every die and shuffled card taken out, which is exactly why it is the natural next step up.

Which Puerto Rico to buy

Puerto Rico has been a fixture of the strategy canon long enough that it earns its place on our best board games top 50 list, so the only real question is which box suits your table.

Version	What it is	Best for
Puerto Rico	The classic Rio Grande English edition, the one every strategy guide is written about	Anyone who wants the real, tournament standard game
Puerto Rico 1897	Ravensburger reimagining with new art and a story layer	Families who want the systems but not the colonial plantation theme

Which is worth flagging, because it is a real reason some families pass. Puerto Rico is a colonial era game and the theme is, generously, pasted over the math. If that theme is going to bother your table, the 1897 edition keeps the systems and swaps the setting. The systems are identical in spirit, so it is a theme decision, not a quality one.

Frequently asked questions

How many players does Puerto Rico support?

Puerto Rico supports 3 to 5 players in the base game, and two players have their own separate setup rather than a ghost player. Three to five is where it is designed and tuned, and the component counts change with the table, so five players is a genuinely longer, tighter game than three.

How many roles are in Puerto Rico and what are they?

There are seven roles: Settler, Mayor, Builder, Craftsman, Trader, Captain, and Prospector. Each round a different player picks one role, everyone at the table performs it, and the three roles nobody took collect a doubloon each for whoever takes them later.

How does a round actually work when only one player gets a bonus?

Every round is a draft, not a single pick, so each player claims one role in turn and all players perform every role that was claimed. The player who picks a role gets a small extra on top, such as the Trader earning 1 extra doubloon, but the point is that the order of picking is the real strategic layer.

How do you score points by shipping in Puerto Rico?

Every good ships for a flat 1 victory point per case, no matter which good it is. The rulebook states plainly that all goods have the same shipping value, so coffee is not worth more than corn on a ship. Where goods differ is in the Trader phase, where the trading house pays a printed 0 to 4 doubloon price.

What triggers the end of a Puerto Rico game?

A game ends when any one of three things happens: the colonists run out, a player fills his 12th city space, or the last victory point chip is taken. The first is checked at the end of the Mayor phase, the second during the Builder phase, and the third during the Captain phase.

How long does a game take and is it good for families?

Expect 60 to 90 minutes once everyone knows the roles, and closer to 2 hours on a first play. The box ages it at 12 and up, and it is a strong family game from roughly 10 up if a parent is teaching, because the lack of dice means a younger player never loses a turn to pure luck.

Do you need to upgrade the coins or buy accessories?

No. Puerto Rico already ships with 60 metal doubloons, so the classic advice to buy metal coins is solving a problem the box does not have. The recommended upgrade is a third party insert only if you hate sorting the one hundred octagonal colonist tokens, and that is a convenience, not a requirement.